Have you ever sent out a mass email on you forum before and it brought back a bunch of old members? I recently brought back Mighty No. 9 Universe, though I did send out a mass email no one seemed to log back in... One thing I can think of is that not everyone has access to those old email accounts anymore. That and the subreddit is basically a ghost town since the game has already been out for years at this point. I have sent out a mass email on a Teen Titans forum and that brought people over to the Discord server, not really back on the forums.