One of my personal takes, however, is that not all forum admins should be treated equally.
Well... you have those admins that are technically competent when it comes to the actual administering of the script and the hosting it's ran on (VPS/dedi specifically)... then you have those that are great on figuring out how to create content that drives traffic...
RARELY do you have an admin that can do both..... the IPS support site is a classic case of that. Most of the admins over there don't deserve the term of "admins"... they are more "managers".
As long as they know that the forum admins that they participate in for advice aren't actually helpful
Not necessarily true.. the issue is that in many cases, Admins may not choose to help on a 3rd party site since there is usually no way to validate if the person requesting help is an actual license holder or not... I prefer NOT to help out someone that is running a pirated copy of a script.
When, in reality, they often regurgitate the same misguided advice (let's talk about SEO optimization when you literally have no valuable content to even optimize! Let's talk about what plugins to install to make your technology unique when you have no unique strategy!).
And here you fall into that fatal trap... not ALL admins are concerned about SEO or such... some are actually in it because they enjoy the simple fact of running and maintaining a site with no concern about "how much traffic I can get and how much I can make from ads, etc".
I think we all eventually learn that we have to have a plan/strategy on content creation.... But once more.... not everyone runs their site with the intent to "rule the world". Some simply run their sites on a paid forum script because it gives them somewhere to post content without worrying about "butt-hurting" an admin and getting their posts/content blocked.
There is MUCH more for many than simple SEO/content concerns... in many cases, there are Admins that are actual administrators that run not only the script, but manage the core underpinnings that support that script. Those have concerns that those "managers" can't answer.
Then you have those that will detail benefits of certain add-ons for specific use cases.
Where I see a site like this (or any admin site) is more for general discussions of pros/cons of scripts, and getting help at the base level of actual server administration. Many of us refuse to provide detailed script support on a site like this because, as I mentioned earlier, WAY to many folks pirate scripts and go looking for support where they can get it since most are blocked from getting it on the actual script support sites.