One of the biggest mistakes many make when starting a new forum is thinking that they will have hundreds of members and constant activity within a few weeks. That is the wrong mindset. I used to be guilty of that when I first started. I would set unrealistic goals and feel let down when I did not reach them.
I think we all were.
I also used to give my forums a year, and that's it. If they didn't grow into this big popular thing in one year, I closed them down.
My hiking brand is a business. It's a trademarked LLC business. It started as a YouTube channel, and in 4 years, it was monetized. It's turning 8 this mont,h and it's a second income. If I had just given it a year and closed it, I'd have missed out on the opportunities I'm raking in right now.
In a few weeks, I'm getting paid $200 for 3 hours to dress up like a sasquatch Santa, all because I'm known as Hiking with Shawn. LOL.
So, now I give my forums 5 years. If they're not an active community in 5 years, they probably won't be. Give it time and enjoy all the little things.
Here's a great example:
I have a Facebook group with 47,000 members. It's really busy, as you can probably imagine. When it first started, it was like going to meet my friends for a chat. I knew everyone. I remembered everyone. I came to the group knowing what I was going to post. 47K members later, and you lose touch. There are people I don't know and plenty who don't know me. It used to be a small town where everyone knew each other; now, it's a city with different social groups, and I'm mainly just administrating it for the most part.
Enjoy your small community. Enjoy being a regular member because one day all you might have to do is admin stuff and very little regular member fun.